Authority: Supreme Court of India, Civil Appeal No. 13301 of 2015 (and No. 13394 of 2015)
Order Date: 19 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellant – Subrata Bhattacharya; Respondents – Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) & others. The dispute centres on PACL Ltd’s alleged operation of an unregistered Collective Investment Scheme (CIS) through various real‑estate investment schemes.
- Regulatory Background: In 1999 SEBI issued notices to PACL to obtain CIS registration or to wind up. PACL contested, and the Rajasthan High Court (judgment dated 28‑11‑2003) quashed the notices, holding that PACL’s activities were purely real‑estate. SEBI appealed; the Supreme Court (order dated 26‑02‑2013) set aside the High Court judgment, treating the 1999 notices as show‑cause notices and directing a de novo adjudication.
- Subsequent Findings: SEBI later concluded PACL was running an unregistered CIS and ordered promoters and directors to refund investors and wind up schemes. The Securities Appellate Tribunal upheld this order. The matter proceeded to the present Civil Appeals.
- Committee Formation: By order dated 02‑02‑2016 the Court constituted the Justice (Retd.) R.M. Lodha Committee to liquidate PACL’s land assets and ensure equitable refund of investor funds. The Committee retrieved title deeds, engaged valuation and audit experts, and formulated sale and refund modalities.
- Interlocutory Applications (IAs): Numerous IAs were filed by plot‑holders/allottees of PACL projects in Sectors 100 and 104 (Mohali) and Bhatinda. The Committee, assisted by chartered accountants, examined the records and categorised the allottees into five categories based on payment mode, amount and timing (see Table 1 below).
- Key Dates Prior to the Present Order:
- 04‑03‑2020: Court directed disclosure of allottees’ names, agreement dates, payment modes, and transfer status.
- 17‑10‑2024: Committee instructed to verify claims with auditor assistance.
- 28‑02‑2025: Committee filed a Final Report.
- 02‑04‑2025: Court sought further recommendations from the Committee.
- 19‑04‑2025: Committee submitted a detailed Report categorising allottees and recommending actions (Amici Note dated 08‑10‑2026).
Categories and Allottee Numbers
| Project | Category | Allottees (Mohali Sector 100) | Allottees (Mohali Sector 104) | Allottees (Bhatinda) |
| I | Full payment through banking channels (sale deed executed or possession certificate issued) | 92 | 241 | 203 |
| II | > 50 % payment through banking channels (before or after 02‑02‑2016) | 227 | 138 | 126 |
| III | < 50 % payment through banking channels | 117 | 66 | 16 |
| IV | Full/partial cash payment or banking payments after 02‑02‑2016 | – (cash cases) | – (cash cases) | – (cash cases) |
| V | Allottees who sold their allotments during pendency, to be treated as per the original category | – | – | – |
Committee Recommendations (Amici Note)
- Category I: Issue sale certificates / No‑Objection Certificates (NOC) to all 92 + 241 + 203 allottees within 8 weeks.
- Category II: Treat as sold; require payment of the balance (including contribution to internal development works) within 30 days, then issue sale certificates/NOC within 8 weeks.
- Category III: Treat as unsold; refund the audited amounts with 8 % interest within three months of a successful auction.
- Category IV: Treat as unsold inventory; sell through public auction with no refund. However, for those who made banking payments after 02‑02‑2016, the Court adopted the Category III approach (refund with 8 % interest).
- Category V: Apply the same treatment as the category the allottee would have belonged to if the sale had not occurred.
Court Directions
1. Category I – Recovery Officer (under Section 28A of the SEBI Act) to issue sale certificates/NOC to the 536 allottees (Annexures 1, 4, 7) within 8 weeks; also to issue possession certificates where not yet issued.
2. Category II – Committee to send each allottee a statement of balance payable (excluding those who paid after 02‑02‑2016) within 8 weeks; allottees must pay the balance within 30 days via banking channels to the account designated by the Committee. Upon receipt, Recovery Officer to issue sale certificates/NOC within 8 weeks. Failure to pay may allow a single 30‑day extension; otherwise the plot is treated as unsold and refunded as per Category III.
3. Category III – Refund the audited amounts with interest at 8 % per annum; payment to be made within three months of a successful auction of the concerned plot. Upon refund, the allottee’s claim is deemed fully satisfied.
4. Category IV (cash payments) – No refund; however, the Court clarified that allottees may pursue civil suits for recovery against PACL, provided the Justice R.M. Lodha Committee, its members, and SEBI are not impleaded.
5. Category IV (banking payments after 02‑02‑2016) – Apply Category III treatment: refund audited amounts with 8 % interest within three months of auction.
6. Category V – Apply the same relief as the original category the allottee would have fallen into.
7. Other IAs – The Committee to verify applications seeking inclusion in Category I (listed in the order) and pass appropriate orders subject to SEBI’s objection, if any.
Final Outcome
- The Supreme Court accepted the Committee’s categorisation and recommendations, issuing detailed directions for issuance of sale certificates, balance‑payment timelines, and refunds with statutory interest. It also clarified that cash‑paying allottees may seek civil remedies, while ensuring that the litigation does not become a protracted specific‑performance suit. The order effectively resolves the pending interlocutory applications and provides a clear pathway for the restitution of investors in the PACL real‑estate schemes.
Topics: PACL, SEBI, Real‑Estate Refunds