Authority: Supreme Court of India

Order Date: 16 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd (RVUNL), a Government of Rajasthan undertaking engaged in electricity generation, versus Parsa Kente Collieries Ltd (PKCL), a joint‑venture formed to develop the Parsa East‑Kanta Basan coal block and supply coal to RVUNL.
  • Procedural History: An arbitral tribunal (Justice Sudhir Kumar Katriar, Retd.) rendered an Award on 15 Jan 2021 and an Additional Award on 5 Jul 2021 concerning nine monetary claims by PKCL. The Commercial Court, Jaipur (No. 1, 2023) set aside both awards on 20 May 2023 under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. PKCL appealed to the Rajasthan High Court (D.B. Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No. 2007 of 2023); the High Court, on 21 May 2026, held the Commercial Court had exceeded its jurisdiction and restored the awards. RVUNL filed the present Special Leave Petition (SLP) under Article 136, seeking to annul the awards.
  • Legal Questions: (i) What is the scope of Article 136 when invoked after a Section 37 appellate decision? (ii) Do the arbitral findings on any of the nine claims suffer from patent illegality, perversity, or any other ground under Section 34(2‑A)? (iii) Did the Commercial Court exceed its jurisdiction in setting aside the awards? (iv) Did the High Court correctly exercise its Section 37 powers?
  • Key Observations: The Court reiterated that Article 136 is a discretionary, exceptional power used only in cases of serious legal error. Section 37 is the final statutory appellate remedy; courts cannot re‑appraise evidence or substitute their own construction of contracts. Patent illegality exists only when an award is perverse, lacks reasoning, or contravenes the Arbitration Act. The Court reviewed each claim, summarising the arbitral findings, the Commercial Court’s reasoning, and the High Court’s conclusions.
  • Claim 1 (rejected coal rakes – Rs 71,77,82,356): Tribunal’s contra‑proferentem reasoning deemed plausible; no patent illegality.
  • Claim 2 (stamp duty – Rs 83,47,64,575): Tribunal’s interpretation of the “adversely and directly” clause was reasonable; Commercial Court’s reading was a jurisdictional over‑reach.
  • Claim 3 (interest on overdue payments – Rs 67,27,40,731): Tribunal’s use of an average bank rate (11.95 %) was a permissible construction; no illegality.
  • Claim 4 (legal fees – Rs 3,75,35,000): Tribunal correctly applied Section 230 of the Contract Act; Commercial Court erred by imposing a limitation bar.
  • Claim 5 (bank guarantee charges – Rs 58,96,93,602): Tribunal’s partial award of Rs 43,59,18,563 based on “all charges” clause was sound; no patent illegality.
  • Claims 6 & 7 (project‑affected families and vocational training centre – Rs 8,01,00,000 and Rs 3,38,71,562): Tribunal treated additional obligations as “change in law” and allowed reimbursement; Commercial Court exceeded its jurisdiction.
  • Claim 8 (land‑acquisition cost – Rs 66,70,00,000): Additional Award correctly addressed an omitted claim; Commercial Court’s limitation ground was misplaced.
  • Claim 9 (interest & costs – 11.95 % simple interest and Rs 2,19,06,176 costs): Tribunal’s discretionary interest award was upheld as plausible.
  • Conclusion of Review: For each claim the Court found no patent illegality or perversity in the arbitral findings. The Commercial Court’s interferences were beyond the scope of Section 34, while the High Court’s restoration of the awards was consistent with the limited appellate jurisdiction under Section 37. Consequently, there is no basis for the Supreme Court to entertain the SLP.

Final Outcome

  • The Special Leave Petition is dismissed with no order as to costs.
  • The High Court judgment dated 21 May 2026 stands affirmed; the arbitral Award dated 15 Jan 2021 and the Additional Award dated 5 Jul 2021 are fully restored.
  • All pending applications, if any, are disposed of.

Topics: Arbitration Law, Supreme Court Judgment