Authority: Supreme Court of India

Order Date: 17-11-2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Petitioner – Samdariya Builders Private Limited; Respondent – Madhya Pradesh Housing and Infrastructure Development Board (MPHIDB) and others.
  • The petitioner submitted a bid under an RFP dated 30‑07‑2026 issued by MPHIDB for densification of the Bhopal Collectorate. The bid was disqualified under Special Eligibility Criteria, Clause 19, because the petitioner had previously completed a MPHIDB project (Government Printing Press, Rewa re‑densification) with a delay exceeding one year.
  • The earlier project was awarded on 08‑09‑2016 with a 24‑month completion period; actual completion incurred a two‑year delay. The Executive Engineer imposed a penalty of Rs 7,30,000. The petitioner deposited Rs 27,88,442 on 12‑03‑2024, including the penalty, without admitting liability.
  • The petitioner argued that the RFP clause imposing a “forever” disqualification for past delays was unconscionable and not legally sustainable. The petitioner did not challenge the clause at the time of tender submission.
  • The High Court of Madhya Pradesh rejected the petition for re‑evaluation of the technical bid and upheld the disqualification.

Final Outcome

  • The Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition, confirming that the technical bid remains disqualified and the financial bid will not be opened.
  • The Court directed MPHIDB to consider any representation filed by the petitioner and to ensure that any future disqualification under the Special Eligibility Criteria is limited to a specified prior period rather than being “forever”.
  • All pending applications, if any, were ordered to stand disposed of.

Topics: Legal Disqualification, Public Procurement