Authority: Supreme Court of India, Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction

Order Date: 19 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Helena Anna Maria Lersch (German citizen, Vice‑President Public Policy, TikTok, based in Singapore) – appellant; Suhaan Mukerji (Indian citizen, practising lawyer, partner of PLR Chambers, New Delhi) – respondent; minor child Marcus Johannes Mukerji, born 15 July 2022.
  • Background: Unmarried parents separated; mother sought access and custody of the four‑year‑old son, alleging denial of access by the father. Multiple proceedings arose: a habeas‑corpus petition in the Bombay High Court (Goa Bench), a guardianship petition under the Guardians and Wards Act 1890 in the Alipore District Court (South‑24 Parganas), and subsequent transfer of that petition to the Patiala House Family Court, New Delhi.
  • Key Chronology:
  • 15 July 2022 – child born in New Delhi.
  • Oct 2022 – family moved to Goa.
  • Oct 2025 – German Embassy issued negative declaration confirming mother as sole legal guardian under German law; child received German passport.
  • Nov 2025 – child taken to Germany, then returned to Goa with mother’s consent.
  • Dec 2025–Jan 2026 – parents explored admission to United World College South East Asia (UWCSEA) in Singapore; father later withdrew consent (04 Feb 2026).
  • 17 Feb 2026 – mother filed habeas‑corpus petition in Bombay High Court; interim custody granted for ten days (27 Feb–8 Mar 2026).
  • 02 Apr 2026 – father obtained ex‑parte order restraining mother in Alipore Family Court.
  • 23 Apr 2026 – Calcutta High Court stayed substantive orders pending jurisdictional determination.
  • 08 Apr 2026 – Bombay High Court ordered supervised video interaction; subsequent obstruction alleged by mother.
  • 25 May 2026 – mother filed fresh application for custody; Bombay High Court granted video interaction but retained father’s physical custody.
  • 19 Jun 2026 – mother filed Special Leave Petition (SLP) before this Supreme Court.
  • Procedural Posture: The Supreme Court, after several hearings, directed mediation, noted the lack of agreement, and decided to intervene under its parens patriae jurisdiction to provide an interim custodial arrangement while the guardianship case proceeds in Delhi.

Final Outcome

  • The Court held it has jurisdiction to grant interim custody.
  • It found the mother has a stronger prima‑facie claim, the balance of convenience favours her, and denying her interim custody would cause irreparable harm to the child.
  • Interim Custody Direction: Mother is granted interim custody and may relocate the child to Singapore for schooling, subject to the following conditions:

1. Mirror Order: Mother must obtain a mirror order from an appropriate Singapore court within three weeks, reflecting the directions of this Court.

2. Security Deposit: Mother must deposit Rs 1 crore in the Court Registry, to be kept in an interest‑bearing fixed‑deposit for two years or until the Delhi guardianship petition is finally disposed of.

3. Passport: Child’s passport remains with the Registry; it will be released to the mother after the mirror order is filed.

4. Custody Schedule (while child remains in Delhi):

  • Monday 12 pm: Father hands child to mother.
  • Tuesday‑Thursday: Mother retains child.
  • Friday 12 pm: Mother hands child back to father.
  • Saturday‑Sunday: Father retains child.

5. Visitation & Communication:

  • Mother to provide daily video‑call access of at least 20 minutes (2 pm–10 pm Singapore time).
  • Father may visit Singapore with prior notice; may retain child from Friday afternoon to Sunday evening, provided school schedule is not disrupted.

6. Education: Mother to enrol the child in UWCSEA, Singapore, or a listed backup school; father must cooperate by providing necessary documents.

7. Health Decisions: While the child is in Singapore, mother makes health decisions; while in India, father makes health decisions.

8. Travel Restrictions: Father may not remove the child from Singapore; mother may not take the child out of Singapore except to India or with explicit permission of the Delhi Family Court.

9. Reporting: Both parents must submit six‑monthly psychological reports to ensure no parental‑alienation syndrome develops.

10. Undertakings: Both parties must file undertakings to comply with all directions within one week.

  • The guardianship petition (Act VIII Case No. 69 of 2026) is transferred to the Patiala House Family Court, New Delhi, which will decide the permanent custodial arrangement.
  • The matter is listed for further hearing on 7 December 2026 at 2 pm.

Topics: Child Custody, International Parenting, Interim Court Orders