Authority: Supreme Court of India

Order Date: 17-11-2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Appellant Bhupinder Singh & Anr vs Respondent Unitech Ltd & Ors, with several interlocutory applications and related SLP (CrL.) No. 5978‑5979/2017.
  • Nature: Civil appeal concerning the financial distress of Unitech Ltd, involving land valuation, project completion, and the appointment of PwC to prepare a forensic/valuation report.
  • Background: The Court previously directed on 14‑10‑2026 that a meeting be held with PwC to explore solutions to four issues arising from the Terms of Reference (ToR). The minutes of that meeting (held on 15‑10‑2026) are reproduced below.

Minutes of Meeting (15‑10‑2026)

  • Attendees: Dr. Ajit Atri (Secretary General), Mr. Rajesh Sharma (Registrar‑Judicial), Mr. Rohit Govil (Partner, PwC – Pan‑India Head of Stressed Assets Resolution), Ms. Shalini Shrivastav (Partner, PwC), Mr. Sandeep Kumar Agarwal (Director, Deals‑BRS, PwC), Mr. Lalit Singh (Legal Representative, PwC), Ms. Ruby Singh Ahuja (Advocate‑on‑Record, Karanjawala & Co., representing PwC), and Mr. Jappanpreet Hora (Assisting Counsel).
  • Issues deliberated: Immunity, Disclaimer & Document Retention, Invoicing, Conflict of Interest, Real‑Estate Valuation.

1. Immunity

  • PwC sought protection from any civil, criminal or administrative claims arising from preparation of the Court‑ordered report.
  • Requested that PwC and any external specialist be barred from being impleaded, summoned or required to participate in any other forum.

2. Disclaimer, Retention of Documents and Invoicing

  • Disclaimer: PwC will rely solely on data/documents furnished by Unitech; it will not independently verify authenticity.
  • Retention: PwC asked to keep copies of all materials and working papers for future reference, subject to Court directions.
  • Invoicing: PwC proposed a single lender to receive its invoice, or alternatively the lenders listed in paragraph 8 of the order dated 27‑05‑2026 could deposit fees with the Court Registry for later disbursement per milestones.

3. Conflict of Interest

  • PwC disclosed existing professional services to several lenders (the same lenders listed in the order) but asserted no conflict of interest for the present assignment.
  • Suggested the assignment be recorded as a “special project” under Supreme Court supervision.

4. Real Estate Valuation

  • PwC will engage an external specialist/valuer for the real‑estate valuation.
  • Requested that the specialist’s fee of ₹ 375 lakh be excluded from PwC’s own professional fee.

Court Directions

1. Immunity – Granted. PwC and any external agency engaged by it are immune from being impleaded, summoned or required to participate in any other litigation concerning the services rendered under this order.

2. Exclusive Review – Only the Supreme Court may scrutinise, review or assess the report; no other court or quasi‑judicial authority may challenge it.

3. Disclaimer – Accepted as per paragraph 3(C) of the ToR. All documents supplied to PwC must be affirmed by affidavit; PwC will rely on them but will conduct a reasonable review.

4. Document Retention – PwC may retain all materials and working papers; stakeholders may obtain a confidentiality agreement from PwC.

5. Conflict of Interest – Existing engagements with lenders do not constitute a conflict; PwC must disclose any future services to the lenders in a sealed cover to the Unitech Board.

6. Special Project – The assignment is treated as a special project under Court supervision.

7. Fee Structure – The professional fee of ₹ 375 lakh excludes external specialist costs. The nine lenders listed below must each deposit Rs 60,00,000 (₹ 60 lakh) with the Court Registry within two weeks. The Registry will invest the amounts in a short‑term fixed deposit and disburse to PwC as per the milestone schedule.

  • JM Financial ARC
  • Suraksha ARC
  • Edelweiss ARC
  • IDBI Bank
  • Canara Bank
  • LIC
  • SREI Equipment Finance Ltd.
  • IL&FS
  • HDFC Bank

(The remaining lenders – Bank of Maharashtra and SICOM – are not required to deposit at this stage.)

Land & Asset Valuation

  • New Managing Director of Unitech (as informed by ASG N. Venkatraman) presented a chart of land inventory:
  • Serial 1.1‑1.11: Project land, free of encumbrances.
  • Serial 2.1‑2.4: Non‑project encumbered land.
  • Serial 3.1‑3.9: Disputed parcels.
  • Serial 4.1‑4.9: Un‑utilised FSI project land.
  • Serial 5.1‑5.3: Project receivables.
  • Serial 6.1‑6.3: Market value of joint‑venture investments.
  • Total estimated value of all parcels (encumbered + unencumbered) plus receivables and inventories: Rs 71,967.25 crore.
  • Projects nearing completion (units sold vs total):

| Project | Total Units | Sold Units |

| Gurugram – Vistas (Towers A1‑A11, B1‑B5, E1‑E2) | 1,007 | 979 |

| Greater Noida – Cascade | 356 | 344 |

| Greater Noida – Horizon | 1,138 | 1,128 |

| Greater Noida – Habitat (Towers 1,3,4,6,8) | 902 | 773 |

| Greater Noida – Verve | 363 | 318 |

| Commercial projects – Aspen Green | 1,043 | 883 |

| Gardens | 256 | 162 |

| Unihomes | 171 | 164 |

| Executive Floors | 156 | 147 |

| Singleton Floors | 27 | 26 |

| Habitat corner, Greater Noida | 54 | 42 |

| Bhubaneshwar One | 250 | 181 |

| Total (all listed) | 5,723 | 5,147 |

  • The Board requires Rs 500 crore to complete the pending projects. The Court permitted the Board to sell the unencumbered parcels (serial 1.1‑1.11) to raise the required funds, subject to verification by all lenders within two days.

Encroachment Issues

  • Assistant Commissioner of Police‑I, Noida (Praveen Kumar Singh) filed an affidavit confirming non‑compliance with the Court’s earlier order (14‑10‑2026) to remove encroachments on plots in Sectors 96‑98 (Maya Nagar).
  • The police have repeatedly sought information from the Noida Development Authority and the District Magistrate but have received no response.
  • The Court directed senior counsel for NOIDA (Mr. Ravindra Kumar) to cooperate fully with the police and district magistrate to ensure swift removal of encroachments.

Interlocutory Applications (IA) Disposed/Listed

  • IA 261064/2025 (Ms Sunaina Goenka, 77‑year‑old home‑buyer, paid ₹ 25 lakh in 2016): Court ordered the Board to grant possession of the flat within two weeks on a provisional occupation certificate and to execute the conveyance deed as done for other occupants. Disposed.
  • IA 180886/2025 – listed for future hearing.
  • IA 251540/2025 and IA 330110/2025 – dismissed.
  • The Court asked the Board to furnish information on repayment of matured fixed deposits of small depositors, including senior citizens, by the next date.
  • Numerous other IA numbers (e.g., 197133/2022, 305405/2026, 286435/2024, etc.) were listed for hearing on 20‑Nov‑2026.

Conclusion / Final Outcome

  • PwC is granted full immunity and its report will be reviewed exclusively by the Supreme Court.
  • Lenders are to fund PwC’s fees via deposits of ₹ 60 lakh each.
  • Unitech may sell unencumbered land parcels to raise ₹ 500 crore for project completion.
  • Encroachment removal is to be coordinated between police, NOIDA Development Authority, and the District Magistrate.
  • Specific home‑buyer IA has been resolved in favour of the applicant.

Topics: Court‑Ordered Immunity, Real‑Estate Valuation, Lender Funding