Authority: Supreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Order Date: 18 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellants – Bibol Toppo & others (residents of Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna villages, Sundergarh District, Odisha); Respondents – State of Odisha and M/s Dalmia Cements Bharat Limited.
- Background: The State of Odisha granted a mining lease to Dalmia Cements for 893.55 ha; after surrender of 20.493 ha the lease stood at 873.057 ha, with mining already underway on 335.96 ha. The company sought surface rights over the remaining 273.57 ha (≈273.57 acres) to expand mining.
- Procedural Timeline:
- 09‑Dec‑2015: Company submitted three proposals under Form A of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
- 23‑Aug‑2017: State gave administrative approval subject to prior‑consent provisions of the 2013 Act.
- 06‑Nov‑2017: Notification under Rule 8 (Odisha Rules) to commence consultation and Social Impact Assessment (SIA).
- 18‑Sep‑2019 & 06‑Jan‑2020: Letters seeking Gram Sabha prior‑consent; Gram Sabha resolutions on 26‑Jan‑2020 rejected the proposal.
- 24‑Feb‑2020: Fresh notification under Section 4(1) of the 2013 Act (due to lapse of six months).
- 18‑Mar‑2021: Notification under Section 5 for public hearing on draft SIA; hearing scheduled for 16‑Apr‑2021 but could not be held due to Covid‑19.
- 01‑Jun‑2021: Final SIA report submitted by Nabakrushna Choudhary Centre for Development Studies.
- 08‑Jun‑2021: Expert Group report conveyed to Collector.
- 22‑Jun‑2021: Declaration under Section 8(2) prepared; served on 24‑Jun‑2021.
- 06‑Jul‑2021: Preliminary notifications under Section 11 issued; appellants filed objections on 18‑Oct‑2021.
- 22‑Oct‑2021: Collector rejected objections and recommended Section 19 notification; issued on 03‑Nov‑2021.
- Dec‑2021 & Jan‑2022: Notices under Section 30(2) issued to recorded owners.
- Writ Petition (C) No. 31638/2022 filed in High Court of Orissa, Cuttack; dismissed on 06‑Sep‑2024 (impugned judgment).
- Key Numbers:
- Lease area: 893.55 ha (original), 873.057 ha (after surrender).
- Mining area in use: 335.96 ha.
- Land sought for acquisition: 273.57 ha (≈273.57 acres).
- Consent figures cited: High Court noted 535 affected persons gave consent in Form J as of 22‑Jan‑2024; respondents claimed 482 families consented; respondents also cited 448 affected persons consented.
- Gram Sabha resolutions (26‑Jan‑2020) unanimously rejected the acquisition.
- Legal Issues Raised:
1. Whether acquisition falls under Section 2(1) (government’s own use) or Section 2(2)(b) (private company for public purpose) of the 2013 Act.
2. Mandatory nature of prior‑consent of at least 80 % of affected families under Section 2(2)(b) and its timing (must be obtained before the government’s Section 8 examination).
3. Mandatory prior‑consent of Gram Sabha under Section 41(3) for Scheduled Areas (the land lies in a Fifth‑Schedule area of Sundergarh).
4. Whether the “continuous‑consent” view of the High Court is permissible.
5. Independence of the Expert Group (inclusion of Mr Ashok Kumar Sahoo, a company advisor).
6. Interaction between the 2013 Act and the Mines & Minerals Development & Regulation Act, 1957 (MMDR Act).
- High Court Findings (appealed): Locus standi of appellants denied; acquisition deemed complementary to mining lease; Section 41 considered directory; prior‑consent viewed as a continuous process; expert group composition upheld.
- Supreme Court Analysis:
- Determined that the dominant purpose of acquisition was for a private company (Dalmia Cements) and thus Section 2(2)(b) applies, making 80 % family consent mandatory and required prior to the Section 8 examination.
- Held that Section 41(3) imposes a mandatory pre‑notification consent requirement for Scheduled Areas; the “as far as possible” and “demonstrable last resort” language in sub‑sections 1‑2 does not render sub‑section 3 directory.
- Found that the State had not produced Form J consent records; the claimed 482/448 consents were unsupported, and consent was not obtained at the required stage.
- Concluded that the High Court’s “continuous‑consent” doctrine contradicts the statutory text and renders a mandatory provision redundant.
- Determined that the Expert Group’s independence was compromised by inclusion of Mr Ashok Kumar Sahoo, a company advisor, violating Section 7’s independence requirement.
- Clarified that the MMDR Act governs mining operations but does not supplant the 2013 Act’s land‑acquisition provisions; both statutes operate in distinct spheres and can be given full effect.
- Rejected the State’s argument that acquisition was for its own use; the acquisition was clearly for the private company’s mining purpose.
- Addressed locus standi, noting that the State’s failure to update records should not preclude appellants from challenging the process.
Final Outcome
- The Supreme Court set aside the land acquisition, the preliminary notifications, and the declaration; the impugned High Court judgment is also set aside.
- The appeal is disposed of; the State is free to initiate a fresh acquisition process, but only in compliance with the 2013 Act’s mandatory consent and SIA requirements.
Topics: Land Acquisition, Prior Consent, Mining Lease