Authority: Supreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction

Order Date: 16 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Appellant Akshay Das (employee) vs. Respondent Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. and others.
  • Background: Das sustained injuries while employed as a helper on a truck (Registration No. OR‑09‑6005). Dr. Anandi Charan Naik, PW‑2, certified 70% permanent disablement and 100% loss of income.
  • Initial Award: Commissioner for Employee's Compensation‑cum‑Divisional Labour Commissioner, Cuttack, in E.C. Case No. 12‑D/2012 awarded compensation of Rs 16,01,224, payable within 30 days with a 50% penalty and 12% interest per annum for delay.
  • High Court Intervention: On appeal by National Insurance Co., the High Court reduced the award to Rs 6,12,599, reasoning that PW‑2 was not an orthopedic specialist, and waived the 50% penalty while directing refund of the amount already deposited with accrued interest.
  • Supreme Court Review: The Court held the High Court erred by acting as an expert to assess disablement and loss of income, stating the specialist qualification of PW‑2 was immaterial.

Final Outcome

  • The Supreme Court set aside the High Court order and affirmed the original compensation of Rs 16,01,224 as awarded by the Commissioner.
  • The insurance company is directed to release the balance amount within six weeks from the date of the order.
  • The previously imposed 50% penalty remains waived.
  • All pending applications, if any, are to stand closed.

Topics: Compensation, Insurance, Labor Law