Authority: Supreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction

Order Date: 16 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Appellant Rekha (minor at the time of incident) versus Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited (JVVNL) and other respondents.
  • Origin: Civil Suit No. 02 of 2015 filed alleging electrocution on 15 July 2011 at ~07:00 A.M. due to alleged negligence of JVVNL in maintaining 11 kV transmission lines between Phunthpura and Harivansh ka Pura‑Pathaur ka Pura.
  • Incident description: Wire reportedly hanging 3‑4 ft above ground; Rekha’s head touched the wire, later removed it by hand, suffered severe burns, right‑hand amputation and permanent handicap. Treated at Primary Health Centre, Basedi; Dr. Ramvilas, Badi; later Agra.
  • Police report: Daily Diary Report recorded on 18 August 2011 at Basedi police station; no police action taken.
  • Respondents’ defence: Claim the story is imaginary; argue any contact with 11 kV line would be instantly fatal; deny existence of low‑tension line at the site; suggest injury occurred at home from a jumper wire.
  • Evidence: Appellant’s own testimony, corroborating witnesses, medical records; respondents’ employee witness admitted he was not on duty on the incident day and acknowledged JVVNL’s responsibility to maintain lines, but could not refute the incident.
  • Trial Court finding: Appellant entitled to compensation; decree ordered JVVNL to pay Rs 8,70,000 with interest at 6% until payment.
  • High Court appeal: Rajasthan High Court, S.B. Civil First Appeal No. 319 of 2016, held the appellant’s story unbelievable, citing contradictions and delay in filing police report, and set aside the trial court decree.
  • Supreme Court reasoning: Held the High Court erred by disbelieving evidence without proper basis; reiterated that appellate courts should not overturn factual findings absent material irregularity; affirmed the trial court correctly applied the pre‑ponderance of probability test; noted strict liability attaches when the incident is established.

Final Outcome

  • The impugned order dated 10 May 2024 (S.B. Civil First Appeal No. 319 of 2016) is set aside.
  • The judgment and decree of the trial court in Civil Case No. 02 of 2015 are restored.
  • JVVNL is ordered to pay Rs 8,70,000 compensation with 6% interest to Rekha.
  • All pending applications are disposed of.

Topics: Electricity Distribution Liability, Civil Compensation Judgment