Authority: Supreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction

Order Date: 16 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Appellant – M/s. Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd (incorporated in Maharashtra, 1986, chemical manufacturing and storage); Respondent – The State Trading Corporation of India (STC).
  • Procedural History:
  • STC filed Company Petition (IB) No. 1975/MB/2018 under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) seeking initiation of CIRP against Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd.
  • NCLT, Mumbai Bench, on 13‑02‑2020 ordered the appellant to pay ₹2,18,88,421 to STC, quantifying it as 25 % of the principal dues under the approved Rehabilitation Scheme (RS).
  • STC appealed to NCLAT; the appeal was dismissed on limitation grounds on 20‑04‑2023, but the Supreme Court later restored it on 02‑04‑2025, leading NCLAT to rehear and allow the appeal on 21‑01‑2026, restoring the company petition to the NCLT.
  • The appellant then filed the present Civil Appeal No. 3097 of 2026 before this Court; a stay on the NCLAT judgment was ordered on 17‑03‑2026.
  • Background of the Dispute:
  • Ganesh Benzoplast had supplied toluene and allied products to STC in 2003 and exported industrial lubricants (2004‑2006).
  • The appellant sought relief under Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA) before BIFR; BIFR declared it a sick industrial unit on 06‑05‑2010 (Case No. 42 of 2009) and appointed an operating agency to prepare a Draft Rehabilitation Scheme (DRS).
  • The DRS (circulated 18‑04‑2013, cut‑off date 31‑03‑2011) was later approved by the Delhi High Court on 04‑12‑2015, becoming a Rehabilitation Scheme (RS). Clause 11.11 of the RS provided that unsecured creditors would be paid 25 % of principal dues in five equal annual instalments, with an option to wait up to seven years for full recovery.
  • Annexure V of the RS listed 191 unsecured creditors; STC did not appear there. It appeared in Annexure VI(a) as a contingent liability (Serial No. 6) with a claimed amount of ₹11.35 crore.
  • STC issued a demand notice on 20‑03‑2018 under Section 8 of the IBC for a total of ₹24,26,44,490 (₹17,00,05,876 export, ₹3,68,62,534 domestic, ₹3,57,76,081 for non‑submission of ‘C’ Forms).
  • The appellant replied on 31‑03‑2018 denying liability and later submitted the required ‘C’ Forms on 30‑01‑2020.
  • The NCLT, noting the RS provision and the settlement offer of ₹1.75 crore dated 04‑10‑2019, quantified the payable amount at ₹2,18,88,421 (25 % of principal dues) and directed payment within 30 days.
  • Legal Issues Considered by the Supreme Court:

1. Whether STC, listed as a contingent liability in the RS, could be treated as an unsecured creditor under Clause 11.11.

2. Whether the payment of 25 % of dues had to be made in five instalments starting 2015, as claimed by STC.

3. The applicability of the Supreme Court’s earlier decisions in Modi Rubber Ltd. v. Continental Carbon India Ltd. and Fertilizer Corporation of India Ltd. v. Coromandel Sacks Pvt. Ltd. regarding the binding nature of a rehabilitation scheme on unsecured creditors.

  • Court’s Reasoning:
  • The Court held that STC’s claim remained a contingent liability because it had never been crystallised; therefore it could not be treated as an unsecured creditor for the purposes of Clause 11.11.
  • The demand notice dated 20‑03‑2018 was issued well within the seven‑year period, but the option of waiting for seven years applies only to unsecured creditors, not to contingent liabilities.
  • The Court emphasized that once a Rehabilitation Scheme is approved, it is binding on all creditors, including those who might later become unsecured creditors; the scheme does not permit a creditor to refuse the scaled‑down settlement.
  • Citing Modi Rubber (2023) 17 SCC 263, the Court reiterated that unsecured creditors cannot decline the scaling‑down of dues, as doing so would defeat the purpose of the scheme.
  • Since STC never challenged its classification as a contingent liability and accepted the lump‑sum payment of ₹2,18,88,421 on 20‑03‑2020 “without prejudice”, there was no remaining dispute for the NCLT to adjudicate.
  • Consequently, the NCLAT’s restoration of the company petition was erroneous; the matter was already closed by the NCLT order.

Final Outcome

  • The Supreme Court set aside the NCLAT judgment dated 21‑01‑2026 (Company Appeal (AT)(INS) No. 753 of 2021).
  • It restored the NCLT order dated 13‑02‑2020 directing Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd to pay ₹2,18,88,421 to the State Trading Corporation of India.
  • Both parties were ordered to bear their own costs.

Topics: Court Judgment, Insolvency & Bankruptcy, Rehabilitation Scheme