Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras

Order Date: 20-11-2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Appellant/Petitioner Mrs. R. Vijaya (employee of Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Ltd, formerly Tamil Nadu Electricity Board) vs. 1) Deputy Secretary/Personnel for Chairman cum Managing Director, TANGEDCO; 2) Chief Engineer, Tiruvannamalai Electricity Distribution Circle, TANGEDCO; 3) Superintending Engineer, Tiruvannamalai Electricity Distribution Circle, TANGEDCO.
  • Service Background: Joined TANGEDCO on 13-12-1985 as Assessor; promoted to Typist (1995), Assistant (2007), Accountant (2009), Assistant Accountant Officer, and finally Deputy Financial Controller (2018).
  • Voluntary Retirement Request: Submitted letter on 28-09-2022 requesting relief from service effective 01-04-2023, citing ill health and family reasons.
  • Withdrawal Request: On 10-11-2022, before the expiry of the three‑month notice period, she submitted a written request to withdraw the voluntary retirement.
  • Employer Action: TANGEDCO issued proceedings on 04-01-2023 relieving her from service, without considering the withdrawal letter.
  • Initial Litigation: Petition filed as W.P.No.19806 of 2023 challenging the 04-01-2023 order; Single Judge allowed the writ, quashed the order and directed the respondent to consider the withdrawal within two months.
  • Respondent’s Subsequent Order: On 18-11-2023, TANGEDCO rejected the withdrawal, citing (i) lack of medical certificate of health improvement, (ii) receipt of terminal benefits without protest, and (iii) Regulation 17(gg)(g) which it interpreted as requiring appointing‑authority approval for any withdrawal.
  • Further Appeal: Petition filed as W.P.No.36222 of 2023 seeking certiorari and mandamus to quash the 18-11-2023 proceedings.
  • Regulatory Framework: Regulation 17(gg)(g) of the Tamil Nadu Electricity Board Service Regulations permits an employee to withdraw the notice of voluntary retirement before acceptance; if acceptance has occurred, withdrawal requires appointing‑authority approval.
  • Key Judicial Findings:
  • The employee’s withdrawal letter (10-11-2022) preceded the appointing‑authority’s approval of the voluntary retirement (approval dated 21-11-2022, acceptance order dated 04-01-2023).
  • Since withdrawal was made before any acceptance, the employee’s right to withdraw is absolute and does not require further approval.
  • The reasons cited by TANGEDCO for rejecting the withdrawal (absence of medical certificate, receipt of benefits, regulatory clause) were either irrelevant or misinterpreted.
  • The court clarified that Regulation 17(gg)(e) and 17(gg)(f) require the appointing authority to pass an order before the expiry of the notice period; failure to do so deems the retirement accepted, but withdrawal before such acceptance remains unrestricted.
  • Procedural History: The Single Judge’s order dated 04-01-2024 (in W.P.No.36222 of 2023) was set aside by the present judgment.

Final Outcome

  • The order dated 04-01-2023 (acceptance of voluntary retirement) is set aside.
  • The proceedings dated 18-11-2023 rejecting the withdrawal are quashed.
  • Mrs. R. Vijaya is reinstated in service, subject to re‑depositing the retirement amount already credited to her bank account.
  • No order as to costs is made.

Topics: Legal Withdrawal of Voluntary Retirement, Employment Law