Authority: Supreme Court of India

Order Date: 29 October 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: State of Uttar Pradesh & Others (Appellants) vs. Grand Slam Fitness (P) Ltd. (Respondent). The respondents are private limited companies dealing in sale of physical exercise and fitness equipment and are registered dealers under the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008.
  • Nature of Proceedings: Civil Appeals No. 291/2011 and No. 293/2011 arising from Writ Petitions (Nos. 534/2009 and 361/2009) challenging revenue orders dated 18‑09‑2008 and 26‑11‑2008 that demanded VAT at 12.5% on fitness equipment for the period April‑July 2008.
  • Key Dispute: Whether the equipment (cross elliptical trainers, treadmills, rowing machines, etc.) qualifies as “sports goods” exempt under Notification No. 1021 dated 09‑04‑2008. The Revenue argued the equipment was not covered by the exemption; the dealers contended it fell under Commodity Code Entry 60 (sports goods, games and toys) and thus was exempt.
  • Lower Court Findings: The High Court set aside the revenue’s tax notices, holding there was no valid reason to exclude the equipment from the definition of sports goods.
  • Supreme Court Reasoning: The Court examined Entry 60 of Schedule‑I, which includes sports goods, games and toys, and juxtaposed it with the exemption in Notification 1021 (which lists “Sports Goods” among exempt items). It concluded that the equipment clearly falls within the definition of sports goods, making the revenue’s tax demand lawful. The Court found no basis to interfere with the revenue’s order.

Final Outcome

  • The Civil Appeals (Nos. 291/2011 and 293/2011) are dismissed.
  • The revenue’s VAT demand at 12.5% on the fitness equipment for the period April‑July 2008 stands affirmed.
  • Any pending applications, if any, are disposed of.

Topics: Taxation, Judicial Decision