Authority: Supreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Order Date: 16 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellant – Twinstar Technologies Ltd (the Successful Resolution Applicant, SRA); Respondents – Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI Ltd, SIDBI and other dissenting financial creditors; additional respondents include Videocon Industries Ltd (VIL), its wholly‑owned subsidiary VOVL Ltd, the Promoter (Mr Venugopal Dhoot), VIL Vendors Association, Union of India, GAIL (India) Ltd, Pertamina, BPRL Ventures, and several intervenors.
- Nature of proceedings: A batch of appeals under Section 62 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (the Code) arising from the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) of VIL and twelve other Videocon group companies, together with the CIRP of VOVL Ltd. The appeals are grouped into:
- Group I – Civil Appeals Nos. 894, 512, 509 of 2022 filed by Twinstar Technologies Ltd challenging the NCLAT judgment dated 05‑01‑2022 which set aside the approval of the SRA’s resolution plan.
- Group II – Appeals concerning the foreign oil‑and‑gas assets (Civil Appeal 1307 2022; Appeals 8659‑8661, 8718‑8719, Diary 41234, 41286 of 2026) filed by the Promoter, VIL Vendors Association and others, arising from NCLAT judgments dated 05‑01‑2022 and 14‑05‑2026.
- Background of the CIRP: Applications under Section 7 of the Code were filed by SBI and other creditors against thirteen Videocon group companies (including VIL) between June and September 2018. The NCLT, Mumbai, consolidated the CIRPs on 08‑08‑2019. The Resolution Professional (RP) invited expressions of interest on 11‑10‑2019 and issued an Information Memorandum on 26‑11‑2019. Eleven resolution plans were received; two (the SRA’s plan and a plan by V Shape Investment Management Ltd) were deemed compliant.
- Key terms of the SRA’s amended plan (filed 07‑11‑2020): Total financial outlay Rs 2,962.02 crores; upfront cash payments of Rs 200 crores to financial creditors, Rs 52 crores to workmen, Rs 10 crores to operational creditors; issuance of non‑convertible debentures (NCDs) of face value Rs 2,700 crores at 6.65 % coupon, redeemable in five instalments (first instalment Rs 200 crores due 25 months after closing, four instalments of Rs 625 crores each in years 3‑6); 8 % equity in VIL to financial creditors; cash balances of the debtors to accrue to financial creditors.
- Committee of Creditors (CoC) voting: On 11‑12‑2020 the SRA’s plan was approved by 95.09 % of the voting share; dissenting creditors (Bank of Maharashtra 1.97 %, IFCI 1.03 %, SIDBI 0.053 %, ABG Shipyard 0.024 %) together held about 3.077 % voting share. The CoC also rejected the Promoter’s Section 12A withdrawal proposal by 98.14 %.
- NCLT approval: On 08‑06‑2021 the NCLT approved the plan under Section 31(1) but directed that dissenting financial creditors be paid their liquidation value in cash upfront. The order was challenged before the NCLAT by the dissenting creditors and the Promoter.
- NCLAT judgment (05‑01‑2022): Set aside the NCLT’s approval, holding that (i) payment to dissenting creditors via NCDs does not satisfy Section 30(2)(b) of the Code; (ii) the NCLT’s direction to pay cash amounted to a modification of the plan, which is beyond its jurisdiction; (iii) the CoC retains the power to reconsider its approval; (iv) prior CCI approval had been obtained (CCI communication dated 08‑12‑2020).
- Subsequent developments: The CoC, in its 25th meeting (12‑01‑2022), resolved to invite fresh expressions of interest; the Supreme Court issued notice on 14‑02‑2022 and directed the CoC not to proceed further.
- Foreign oil‑and‑gas assets: The assets comprise interests in four Brazilian concessions and the Nunukan block in Indonesia, held through subsidiaries VOVL, VHHL, VEBL (BVI), VINI (Cayman). The NCLAT (14‑05‑2026) set aside the NCLT order of 12‑02‑2020 that had attempted to include these assets in VIL’s CIRP, holding that subsidiaries are separate legal entities and assets of subsidiaries cannot be treated as assets of the corporate debtor under the Explanation to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d) of the Code.
- Key submissions: The SRA argued that the CoC cannot revisit an approved plan; the dissenting creditors (Bank of Maharashtra) argued that payment to dissenters must be in cash; the CoC contended it may reconsider in public interest; the Promoter sought inclusion of foreign assets and raised allegations of fraud; the VIL Vendors Association supported the Promoter’s view; intervenors (Union of India, GAIL) raised ancillary issues.
- Legal analysis: The Court examined (i) the jurisdiction of NCLT and NCLAT vis‑à‑vis a CoC‑approved plan; (ii) the power of NCLAT to remit a plan to the CoC; (iii) compliance of the plan with Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b); (iv) whether prior CCI approval was required; (v) the role and continued existence of the CoC (the CoC is not functus officio until the plan is finalised or liquidation ordered).
- Conclusions on legal questions:
- The CoC may revisit its approval before finality; it is not functus officio.
- NCLAT has the power to remit a non‑compliant plan to the CoC; such remand is appropriate where the defect is legal rather than commercial.
- The SRA’s plan violated Section 30(2)(b) because payment to dissenting creditors was via NCDs, not cash.
- Prior CCI approval had been obtained, satisfying the proviso to Section 31(4).
- Foreign oil‑and‑gas assets belong to subsidiaries and are excluded from VIL’s CIRP under the Code.
Final Outcome
- The Supreme Court dismissed all Group I appeals (Civil Appeals 894, 512, 509 of 2022) and affirmed the NCLAT’s order remitting the resolution plan to the CoC.
- The Court dismissed all Group II appeals (Civil Appeal 1307 2022; Appeals 8659‑8661, 8718‑8719, Diary 41234, 41286 of 2026), confirming that the foreign oil‑and‑gas assets cannot be treated as assets of Videocon Industries Ltd in the CIRP.
- Interlocutory applications filed by GAIL and the Union of India were disposed of without prejudice; GAIL’s claim will be dealt with by the RP under the Code, and the Union may raise its contentions before the RP and adjudicating authority.
- No order as to costs was made.
Topics: Insolvency Law, Corporate Restructuring, Competition Law