Authority: High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Circuit Bench at Kolhapur
Order Date: Reserved on 23 October 2026; Pronounced on 20 November 2026
Case Overview
- Petitioners: Shri Rajendra Sureshrao Ghogare, Vinit Suryakant Borawake, Atul Prabhakar Pawar, Pandurang Haridas Rede Patil and other borrowers/guarantors of loans from Vidyanand Co‑Operative Bank Ltd., Solapur.
- Respondents: Vidyanand Co‑Operative Bank Ltd., various cooperative society registrars, and M/s Shriram Construction along with individual respondents.
- Petitioners challenged the judgment and order dated 13 May 2026 of the Divisional Joint Registrar under Section 154 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960, which set aside earlier orders of Assistant Registrars and remanded the matters for fresh consideration.
- Central legal issue: Whether the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (RDB Act) bars the jurisdiction of cooperative courts and the Divisional Joint Registrar in recovery proceedings initiated by a state‑registered cooperative bank, or whether Section 101 of the 1960 Act provides an independent remedy.
- Petitioners relied on Section 18 of the RDB Act, Supreme Court judgments in Pandurang Ganpati Chaugule vs Vishwasrao Patil Murgud Sahakari Bank Ltd. (2020) and Greater Bombay Co‑operative Bank Ltd. vs United Yarn Tex (2007), and argued that Parliament lacks competence to legislate on cooperative bank recoveries.
- Respondent‑Bank argued that the Supreme Court’s decision in Pandurang Chaugule concerned the SARFAESI Act and does not preclude the use of Section 101, citing Supreme Agro Trade and A. Navinchandra Steel cases.
Observations & Reasoning
- The Court noted that Vidyanand Co‑Operative Bank is a state‑registered cooperative bank, not a multi‑state entity, and the loan amount exceeded Rs 10 lakh, with outstanding dues over Rs 1 crore.
- Section 18 of the RDB Act confers exclusive jurisdiction to the Recovery Tribunal for debts covered by Section 17, but the Court examined constitutional entries (List I Entry 45 and List II Entry 32) and Supreme Court pronouncements.
- The Court reproduced the Bombay High Court full‑bench decision in Narendra Kantilal Shah vs Joint Registrar (2004) that post‑constitution of the Recovery Tribunal, cooperative courts lose jurisdiction over recovery of dues.
- However, the Supreme Court in Greater Bombay Co‑operative Bank Ltd. clarified that cooperative banks are not “banking companies” under the Banking Regulation Act and thus the RDB Act does not apply to them; banking activities fall under List I Entry 45, while incorporation and regulation remain under List II Entry 32.
- The constitutional bench in Pandurang Chaugule further held that cooperative banks are governed by both List I Entry 45 for banking matters and List II Entry 32 for other aspects, and that SARFAESI provisions apply to them.
- The Single Judge observed that Parliament deliberately omitted cooperative banks from the RDB Act, providing them with self‑contained remedies under state cooperative legislation.
- Consequently, the Court found merit in the respondent’s argument that Section 101 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 remains a viable remedy notwithstanding the RDB Act.
Final Outcome
- The writ petitions (Nos. 4136, 4137, 4165 of 2026) are dismissed.
- The remedy under Section 101 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 is upheld, allowing Vidyanand Co‑Operative Bank to pursue recovery.
- The question of whether the RDB Act bars recovery proceedings by state cooperative banks is referred to a larger bench of the High Court for authoritative determination.
- The proceedings before the Assistant Registrar are to be expedited.
Topics: Jurisdiction, Cooperative Banking