Authority: Calcutta High Court

Order Date: 19 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Petitioners (seven accused in CRR 2828/2017 and two accused in CRR 142/2016) sought quashing of criminal proceedings under Sections 138/141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, filed by the complainant, Wide Range Sales Pvt. Ltd.
  • The complaint alleged that the accused, as directors/officers of Tantia Constructions Limited, had obtained an inter‑corporate deposit of Rs 1,00,00,000 on 14‑06‑2012, renewed on 01‑04‑2014, and issued a cheque (No. 008233 dated 01‑07‑2014) for repayment, which was dishonoured with the remark “Exceeds Arrangement” on 11‑09‑2014.
  • The complainant issued demand notices, the magistrate summoned the accused, and the petitioners argued they were innocent, not involved in the cheque issuance, and held only independent director or company secretary positions.
  • The petitioners contended that Section 141 of the NI Act requires a specific averment of the accused’s role in the transaction; mere designation as director should not attract liability.
  • The opposite party argued that the accused were full‑time directors/managing directors/additional directors/secretaries and directly involved in day‑to‑day affairs, thus liable.
  • Both sides relied on extensive Supreme Court and High Court precedents concerning vicarious liability of directors under Sections 138/141.

Final Outcome

  • The Court held that independent directors and a company secretary (Tarun Chaturvedi, Madhuchhanda Chatterjee, and Md. Jamshed Alam) were not shown to be in charge of the business at the relevant time; proceeding against them would be an abuse of process and therefore quashed.
  • The Court found that the complaint did not specifically allege the role of the three petitioners, and under the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence, such persons cannot be held liable without clear attribution.
  • For the remaining accused persons (full‑time directors, additional directors, etc.), the Court found the complaint sufficiently identified their positions; thus, the proceedings against them will continue.
  • Consequently, CRR No. 2828 of 2017 is partly allowed, CRR No. 142 of 2016 is allowed, and any interim orders are vacated. The judgment is to be transmitted to the trial court for further action.

Topics: Criminal Law, Negotiable Instruments Act