Authority: High Court at Calcutta (Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction) Original Side

Order Date: 20 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Petitioners – Rajaram Sevak Multipurpose Cold Storage (P) Ltd. & its directors; Respondent – Punjab National Bank (PNB).
  • Nature of proceedings: Writ Petition (WPO 341 of 2024) challenging the bank’s classification of the petitioners’ loan account as a “fraud account”.
  • Background: The petitioners, engaged in organic manure manufacturing and cold‑storage operations, obtained credit facilities initially from Canara Bank (₹24 lakhs) later enhanced by United Bank of India to ₹50 lakhs. Subsequent acquisitions increased exposure; they claim stress due to demonetisation, potato‑market decline, COVID‑19, and RBI restructuring circulars.
  • Bank’s actions: PNB issued a show‑cause notice on 27 December 2023 (later referred to as 21 December 2023) demanding reasons why the account should not be classified as fraud. On 4 April 2024 the petitioners were informed that the account had been classified as fraud. The bank cited RBI Master Directions on Frauds (1 July 2016, updated 23 July 2016) and its internal FRMD Circular No. 70/2023 dated 20 October 2023.
  • Procedural history: Earlier writ petition WPA 9820 of 2021 was dismissed; intra‑court appeal MAT 643 of 2021 restrained SARFAESI actions. On 5 August 2025 the writ petition was allowed; the bank appealed (MAT 1887 of 2025). The bank also instituted OA 440 of 2022 before the Debt Recovery Tribunal under Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993.
  • Petitioners’ grievance: The forensic audit report (FAR) on which the fraud classification was based was not furnished in full; only extracts were allegedly provided. They argue this breaches the RBI‑mandated procedure and the principles of natural justice (audi alteram partem).
  • Bank’s defence: Claims extracts of the FAR were supplied with the show‑cause notice; full report withheld to protect confidential information of bank officials and third parties. Asserts compliance with FRMD Circular and RBI directions, and that the petitioners were given a reasonable opportunity to reply.
  • Legal precedents cited: Supreme Court decisions in State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal (2023), State Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Ltd. (2026 INSC 323), and Hemanta Kanoria v. Bank of India (2024 SCC OnLine Cal 1012). The court notes that the Supreme Court mandates furnishing the entire forensic audit report, subject to justified redaction, and that a personal oral hearing is not a statutory right.

Final Outcome

  • The communication dated 21 March 2024 informing the petitioners of the fraud‑account classification is set aside.
  • The show‑cause notice dated 21 December 2023 (as per the order) is revived.
  • PNB shall furnish the complete forensic audit report relied upon for the proposed classification, subject only to permissible redactions with recorded reasons for any withheld portions.
  • Upon receipt, the petitioners will be given a reasonable opportunity to submit written representations on the findings and conclusions of the report.
  • The bank’s competent authority must consider the representations independently and pass a fresh, reasoned order in compliance with RBI Directions.
  • The court expresses no opinion on the merits of the alleged fraud, diversion, or criminal breach of trust; those matters remain for the bank’s authority and the Debt Recovery Tribunal.
  • No order as to costs; urgent certified copy of the order may be supplied upon formal request.

Topics: Banking Regulation, Fraud Account Classification