Authority: High Court at Calcutta (Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
Order Date: 20 November 2026
Case Overview
- Petitioners: Ridhi Sidhi Cold Storage Pvt. Ltd. and its directors (Petitioners Nos. 2 & 4) vs. Respondent: Punjab National Bank (PNB) and others.
- The petition challenges a show‑cause notice dated 12 December 2023 and a subsequent communication dated 29 December 2023 that classified the petitioners’ loan account as a “fraud account”.
- Background: The petitioners, engaged in organic manure manufacturing, originally obtained a Rs 24 lakh credit facility from Canara Bank, later taken over and enhanced to Rs 50 lakh by United Bank of India (now merged with PNB). Subsequent acquisition of several NPA cold‑storage units increased exposure; they claim stress due to demonetisation, potato‑market decline, COVID‑19 moratoriums, and RBI restructuring circulars.
- Earlier litigation: Writ petition WPA 9820 2021 (interim relief denied on 8 July 2021; status‑quo order on 26 July 2021). OA 407 2022 filed before the Debt Recovery Tribunal under the Recovery of Debts Act. The show‑cause notice and fraud classification were issued thereafter.
- The bank’s position: Loan accounts were classified as NPA per RBI Master Directions (1 July 2016, updated 23 July 2016) and FRMD Circular No. 70/2023 (20 Oct 2023). A forensic audit report (FAR) was relied upon; the bank alleges the petitioners did not cooperate with auditors and that extracts of the FAR were furnished with the notice.
- Procedural history in the courts: Coordinate Bench set aside the 29 Dec 2023 letter on 29 April 2024; the bank appealed and the appeal was allowed on 16 September 2025 on the ground that the petitioners’ affidavit‑in‑opposition was not filed, leading to remand for fresh consideration. The bank subsequently disclosed an internal order dated 11 March 2024, claimed as the final fraud‑classification order, but the petitioners argue it was never communicated.
- Legal principles cited: Supreme Court decisions in State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal (2023), SBI v. Amit Iron Private Ltd. (2026 INSC 323), and Hemanta Kanoria v. Bank of India (2024 SCC OnLine Cal 1012). These establish the requirement of audi alteram partem, disclosure of the entire forensic audit report (subject to justified redaction), and that internal bank circulars cannot override Supreme Court law.
Final Outcome
- The communication dated 21 March 2024 informing the petitioners of the fraud classification is set aside.
- The show‑cause notice dated 12 December 2023 is revived.
- PNB shall furnish the complete forensic audit report relied upon for the classification, permitting only those portions to be redacted that are justified on privacy or third‑party grounds, and must record specific reasons for any withholding.
- Upon receipt of the full report, the petitioners shall be given a reasonable opportunity to submit written representations on its findings.
- The competent authority of PNB must then consider the representations and pass a fresh, reasoned order in compliance with RBI Directions.
- The Court makes no determination on the merits of the alleged fraud, diversion, or criminal breach of trust; those matters remain for the bank’s internal authority and the Debt Recovery Tribunal.
- No order as to costs; the court may issue a certified copy of the order upon proper application.
Topics: Bank Fraud Classification, Natural Justice