Authority: Supreme Court of India
Order Date: 04 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Petitioners – Kishore Avarsekar and others; Respondents – Assets Care and Reconstruction Enterprises Ltd. (an Asset Reconstruction Company) and others.
- Nature of Proceeding: Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No. 20619/2026 challenging a High Court judgment dated 3 August 2026 that dismissed a writ petition (Criminal Writ Petition No. 2776 of 2023) filed by the petitioners.
- Background: The petitioners were accused under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. They argued that an ARC, which had acquired the bank’s financial assets (including the dishonoured cheques) under a deed of assignment pursuant to Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act, could not be substituted as the complainant in the pending criminal prosecution.
- Key Legal Questions:
1. Whether Section 5(4) and (5) of the SARFAESI Act permit an ARC to substitute itself as complainant in a pending Section 138 NI Act proceeding.
2. Whether the ARC, by virtue of the deeming fiction in Section 5(2), becomes a “holder in due course” and thus a valid complainant.
- Counsel’s Submissions: Senior Advocate Siddhartha Dave contended that there is no Supreme Court precedent, cited two Delhi High Court decisions and one Bombay High Court decision, and argued that the statutory language of Section 5 should be read to exclude the ARC’s right to substitute. He also raised concerns that allowing such substitution would turn criminal prosecutions into tradable financial assets.
- Court’s Reasoning:
- The Court rejected reliance on decisions involving Section 446 of the Companies Act and Section 14 of the IBC, noting the different statutory milieu.
- It examined the assignment agreement between the original lender (Axis Bank Ltd.) and the ARC, which expressly included the three post‑dated cheques, return memos, and demand notice under Section 138.
- A detailed reading of Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act showed that:
- Sub‑section (1) allows acquisition of financial assets.
- Sub‑section (2) deems the ARC the lender, vesting all rights of the bank.
- Sub‑section (3) preserves all related contracts and deeds.
- Sub‑section (4) ensures continuity of any suit, appeal or “other proceeding of whatever nature” pending at the time of acquisition.
- Sub‑section (5) permits the ARC, with the originator’s consent, to apply to courts/tribunals for substitution of its name in such proceedings.
- The Court held that the phrase “other proceeding of whatever nature” is deliberately wide and not limited by ejusdem generis; therefore, a criminal complaint under Section 138 NI Act falls within its ambit.
- However, the Court added a caveat: substitution does not automatically make the ARC the payee or holder in due course. The ARC must prove:
1. The dishonoured cheque was transferred and delivered to it along with the financial asset.
2. An endorsement/assignment sufficient to render it a holder in due course under Sections 8 and 9 of the NI Act.
3. All ingredients of Section 138 are satisfied.
4. No attempt to improve upon the original creditor’s case.
- These factual issues must be decided on evidence at trial.
Final Outcome
- The Special Leave Petition is dismissed.
- The High Court’s judgment upholding the ARC’s right to substitute as complainant (subject to the holder‑in‑due‑course requirements) stands.
- All other contentions of the petitioners remain open for argument before the trial magistrate.
- Any connected applications, if any, are disposed of.
Topics: Asset Reconstruction, Negotiable Instruments Act, SARFAESI Act