Authority: Appellate Authority under RTI Act, Securities and Exchange Board of India
Order Date: November 16, 2026
Case Overview
The appeal was filed by Gondaliya Amirali Mahmadali against the CPIO, SEBI, Mumbai regarding an RTI application dated October 01, 2026. The appellant sought information about the basis on which SEBI granted broker license to Angel One, alleging severe service deficiencies. The appellant detailed specific instances where he attempted to apply for Offer for Sale (OFS) issues of LIC (on August 5, 2026) and Hindustan Copper (on August 26, 2026) through Angel One's platform. He reported persistent system failures including call wait times of 100-135 calls with 15-25 minute waiting periods followed by disconnections, which prevented him from submitting applications despite transferring funds (₹199,999 for his account, ₹200,000 for his wife's account, and ₹200,000 for his son's account). The appellant also raised questions about Angel One's business lending practices and transparency regarding funding sources.
The respondent (CPIO, SEBI) declined to provide the information, stating that the request constituted a grievance redressal matter rather than information as defined under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act. The respondent advised the appellant to use SEBI's SCORES portal for lodging complaints against regulated intermediaries.
The Appellate Authority examined the application, response, and appeal grounds. It concurred with the respondent's view that the request was essentially a grievance about broker services rather than a request for information. The authority cited the Central Information Commission's order in Mr. Surendra Vishwakarma vs. President Secretariat (April 29, 2016) which established that RTI Act cannot be used to compel action or grievance resolution.
Final Outcome
The appeal was dismissed, upholding the respondent's decision. The Appellate Authority found no deficiency in SEBI's response and declined to interfere with the decision. The appellant was directed to use SEBI's SCORES portal for grievance redressal regarding securities market intermediaries.
Topics: RTI Appeal, Broker Regulation, Investor Grievance